Wind Deflector - bit of a disappointment!
Wind Deflector - bit of a disappointment!
Fitted the perspex wind deflector from Just Roadsters last night, tried it today with the top down didn't see\feel any difference still a force 7 gale at 30mph and above somewhat disappointed with it, not having owned a convertible before is this norm am I expecting to much? I have the seat as low as possible I am 6ft though, any suggestions?
-
- Joined: Fri 18 Feb, 2011 22:02
- Posts: 73
I've had both the mesh rollhoop type and non-rollhoop type and they both make a big difference, particularly at motorway speeds. To get max effect you need the side windows up. And I'm 6ft too.
To do a proper test you need to find yourself a nice lady with long hair and take her for a drive both with and without. If the deflector is any good, she won't look like she's been dragged through a hedge backwards...
Cheers R.
To do a proper test you need to find yourself a nice lady with long hair and take her for a drive both with and without. If the deflector is any good, she won't look like she's been dragged through a hedge backwards...
Cheers R.
Arctic Silver '99 Z3 1.9 & Black '59 Frogeye 1275cc
What, you have to shave her hair off part way through the test??? Only joking.Robert T wrote:To do a proper test you need to find yourself a nice lady with long hair and take her for a drive both with and without.
I've got the mesh deflector too, and it makes a huge difference for me as well. With the windows up and deflector in place there's only a slight breeze through my 'fine' hair...
Ian
I think when discussed before the general concensus was the perspex deflector looks better but isn't quite as affective as the mesh type, I would have thought the point its actually mesh is to aid air flow so doesn't go blowing around behind the seats. Never tried the the perspex type so can't compare but from the practicality side of it compared to BMW's mesh deflector its a
Tim.
Tim.
Wind deflector - or lack of one!
I have a mesh deflector which is the wrong model for my car so have to do without.
I agree, driving without is unpleasant at 40mph and above and I imagine would be very tiring on a long journey.
However, I think I've found a solution - drive with the driver's window down and the heater on. The wind immediately stops and the heater can be adjusted to how you want.
Try it - and see what you think.
I agree, driving without is unpleasant at 40mph and above and I imagine would be very tiring on a long journey.
However, I think I've found a solution - drive with the driver's window down and the heater on. The wind immediately stops and the heater can be adjusted to how you want.
Try it - and see what you think.
Wind deflector - or lack of one!
I have a mesh deflector which is the wrong model for my car so have to do without.
I agree, driving without is unpleasant at 40mph and above and I imagine would be very tiring on a long journey.
However, I think I've found a solution - drive with the driver's window down and the heater on. The wind immediately stops and the heater can be adjusted to how you want.
Try it - and see what you think.
I agree, driving without is unpleasant at 40mph and above and I imagine would be very tiring on a long journey.
However, I think I've found a solution - drive with the driver's window down and the heater on. The wind immediately stops and the heater can be adjusted to how you want.
Try it - and see what you think.
Re: Wind deflector - or lack of one!
Thats worth a try, will go out and give that a go shortly!John1950 wrote:I have a mesh deflector which is the wrong model for my car so have to do without.
I agree, driving without is unpleasant at 40mph and above and I imagine would be very tiring on a long journey.
However, I think I've found a solution - drive with the driver's window down and the heater on. The wind immediately stops and the heater can be adjusted to how you want.
Try it - and see what you think.
I'm surprised that you can't tell any difference even with a perspex deflector.
I had the chance to try several over the years but have retained the original mesh one.
They do partially restrict visibility through the rear view mirror (but you've got two door mirrors to cover that problem)
There are a few perspex variants out there but Simon's are (in my opinion) the best non-mesh ones available.
If you're not happy with it, perhaps Simon would consider re-stocking it, or you could sell it.
I had the chance to try several over the years but have retained the original mesh one.
They do partially restrict visibility through the rear view mirror (but you've got two door mirrors to cover that problem)
There are a few perspex variants out there but Simon's are (in my opinion) the best non-mesh ones available.
If you're not happy with it, perhaps Simon would consider re-stocking it, or you could sell it.
If your hissed off with the perspex deflector this seems a bit of a bargain
http://www.zroadster.net/forum/viewtopi ... 158#282158
Assuming you have roll hoops
Tim.
http://www.zroadster.net/forum/viewtopi ... 158#282158
Assuming you have roll hoops
Tim.
Wind deflector
So those who don't have hoops - an even better bargain...
I've got a BMW mesh type with attachment spigots at 75cm apart.
Looking to swap with another mesh with spigots at 70cm for my model.
Contact me at:
John Walker
M: 0781 281 0074
T: 02392 366031
E: jmrwalker@virginmedia.com
I've got a BMW mesh type with attachment spigots at 75cm apart.
Looking to swap with another mesh with spigots at 70cm for my model.
Contact me at:
John Walker
M: 0781 281 0074
T: 02392 366031
E: jmrwalker@virginmedia.com
- whiteminks
- Joined: Tue 26 Sep, 2006 09:58
- Posts: 2768
- Location: Lincoln
I can definitely vouch for the mesh wind deflector.
My hair is mental: With the deflector up I can see where I am going.
With it down I can't see where I am going, get whipped in the face and end up with 'dreads' Bob Marley would have been proud of!
My hair is mental: With the deflector up I can see where I am going.
With it down I can't see where I am going, get whipped in the face and end up with 'dreads' Bob Marley would have been proud of!
big cheesy wrote:'I nearly cacked my trolleys till I quickly tuned in'. Yorkshire Cruise 2008.
Tried with blower on can only say it was very marginal, wife seems to be ok but she is only 5ft, unfortunately that one would appear to have a buyer for it already but thanks for the link, when you say roll over hoops are you referring to the chrome ones or the black, which I have, may have a solution, have a #2 haircut, wear a flat cap or get a pilots helmet tally ho old boy! Looks like I'm on the look out for a mesh one now, shame really as the perspex one looks good.
Didn't try it with the window down though, give that a go tomorrow....MickJ wrote:Tried with blower on can only say it was very marginal, wife seems to be ok but she is only 5ft, unfortunately that one would appear to have a buyer for it already but thanks for the link, when you say roll over hoops are you referring to the chrome ones or the black, which I have, may have a solution, have a #2 haircut, wear a flat cap or get a pilots helmet tally ho old boy! Looks like I'm on the look out for a mesh one now, shame really as the perspex one looks good.
We have just fitted the perspect breaker and i have to admit it isnt as good as the mesh one, but it is still 100% improvement than without it. We have also just upgraded to the chrome hoops from the black ones. We will use the perspect one for summer and change to the mesh one over the winter months.
bill
bill
Uploaded with ImageShack.com
Z3 3.0 Sports Sold
Z4 3.0si Ruby Black with Champagne Leather and Piano Black Dash
Z3 3.0 Sports Sold
Z4 3.0si Ruby Black with Champagne Leather and Piano Black Dash
-
- Joined: Tue 26 Jan, 2010 19:44
- Posts: 1026
- Location: mars
Re: Wind Deflector - bit of a disappointment!
I have both the mesh and perspex deflector and both have pro's and con's. I am over 6' but don't have the same problem you seem to have with windMickJ wrote:Fitted the perspex wind deflector from Just Roadsters last night, tried it today with the top down didn't see\feel any difference still a force 7 gale at 30mph and above somewhat disappointed with it, not having owned a convertible before is this norm am I expecting to much? I have the seat as low as possible I am 6ft though, any suggestions?
Without sounding ridiculous (which i am) some people carry more height than others in there bodies others have longer legs (this sounds silly doesn't it) so if you have the longer body your head sticks up higher and therefore you get more wind! I know what I mean but am having trouble expressing it tonight. I have long leg's ( i sound like a freak now) so my head ...ahh sod it.. wheres me beer
Opinions are like assholes, everybody has one. Harry Callahan.
BMW dust caps x 4 (replica)
Little Tree Air Freshener-Vanillaroma (now worn out and in the bin)
2006 AA road atlas (with the latest safety cameras)
BMW dust caps x 4 (replica)
Little Tree Air Freshener-Vanillaroma (now worn out and in the bin)
2006 AA road atlas (with the latest safety cameras)
They will be comming for you soon Jamezee
Are you getting some time off for this cruise, go on you know you want tooooo
bill
Are you getting some time off for this cruise, go on you know you want tooooo
bill
Uploaded with ImageShack.com
Z3 3.0 Sports Sold
Z4 3.0si Ruby Black with Champagne Leather and Piano Black Dash
Z3 3.0 Sports Sold
Z4 3.0si Ruby Black with Champagne Leather and Piano Black Dash
270+ miles of some of the best roads in yorkshire and the lakes, with cracking company, come on
bill
bill
Uploaded with ImageShack.com
Z3 3.0 Sports Sold
Z4 3.0si Ruby Black with Champagne Leather and Piano Black Dash
Z3 3.0 Sports Sold
Z4 3.0si Ruby Black with Champagne Leather and Piano Black Dash
I wonder if they would be able to change the date of the wedding to accommodate this cruise......and we could call it ' not the royal wedding cruise'
I shall drop the happy couple a line
I shall drop the happy couple a line
Opinions are like assholes, everybody has one. Harry Callahan.
BMW dust caps x 4 (replica)
Little Tree Air Freshener-Vanillaroma (now worn out and in the bin)
2006 AA road atlas (with the latest safety cameras)
BMW dust caps x 4 (replica)
Little Tree Air Freshener-Vanillaroma (now worn out and in the bin)
2006 AA road atlas (with the latest safety cameras)
Re: Wind Deflector - bit of a disappointment!
Actually thats not daft at all, I am longer in the body and tend to sit tall in the car which could be the problem, will just have to live with it, and the wife would agree that I have a problem with wind!Jamezee wrote:I have both the mesh and perspex deflector and both have pro's and con's. I am over 6' but don't have the same problem you seem to have with windMickJ wrote:Fitted the perspex wind deflector from Just Roadsters last night, tried it today with the top down didn't see\feel any difference still a force 7 gale at 30mph and above somewhat disappointed with it, not having owned a convertible before is this norm am I expecting to much? I have the seat as low as possible I am 6ft though, any suggestions?
Without sounding ridiculous (which i am) some people carry more height than others in there bodies others have longer legs (this sounds silly doesn't it) so if you have the longer body your head sticks up higher and therefore you get more wind! I know what I mean but am having trouble expressing it tonight. I have long leg's ( i sound like a freak now) so my head ...ahh sod it.. wheres me beer
Re: Wind Deflector - bit of a disappointment!
Thank you, I thought I was going mad for a whileMickJ wrote:Actually thats not daft at all, I am longer in the body and tend to sit tall in the car which could be the problem, will just have to live with it, and the wife would agree that I have a problem with wind!Jamezee wrote:I have both the mesh and perspex deflector and both have pro's and con's. I am over 6' but don't have the same problem you seem to have with windMickJ wrote:Fitted the perspex wind deflector from Just Roadsters last night, tried it today with the top down didn't see\feel any difference still a force 7 gale at 30mph and above somewhat disappointed with it, not having owned a convertible before is this norm am I expecting to much? I have the seat as low as possible I am 6ft though, any suggestions?
Without sounding ridiculous (which i am) some people carry more height than others in there bodies others have longer legs (this sounds silly doesn't it) so if you have the longer body your head sticks up higher and therefore you get more wind! I know what I mean but am having trouble expressing it tonight. I have long leg's ( i sound like a freak now) so my head ...ahh sod it.. wheres me beer
Let me know when you find a cure for the wind
Opinions are like assholes, everybody has one. Harry Callahan.
BMW dust caps x 4 (replica)
Little Tree Air Freshener-Vanillaroma (now worn out and in the bin)
2006 AA road atlas (with the latest safety cameras)
BMW dust caps x 4 (replica)
Little Tree Air Freshener-Vanillaroma (now worn out and in the bin)
2006 AA road atlas (with the latest safety cameras)
Damm looks like we missed the £55 mesh wind breaker!
Looking for one for a 98 Z3 with the original black plastic hoops, anyone have one for sale?
A few on ebay and seem to fetch anything between £50 and £150!
Looked on a few of the parts sites but couldn't see the price for a genuine new one, any idea what we should be looking to pay?
Looking for one for a 98 Z3 with the original black plastic hoops, anyone have one for sale?
A few on ebay and seem to fetch anything between £50 and £150!
Looked on a few of the parts sites but couldn't see the price for a genuine new one, any idea what we should be looking to pay?
-
- Joined: Tue 21 Jul, 2009 19:14
- Posts: 928
- Location: Eastbourne
Thats not unfortunate for you hang em!! I'd get as much as you can for it..........................................tbh i think with a little discount from cotswold i'd rather buy a new one and know its going to be the correct one for the car, the postage is free too.
Last edited by Julie Z3 on Sun 27 Mar, 2011 10:48, edited 1 time in total.
Helps brake up light dazzle from those people who run very bright bulbs. I found the mesh one made an improvement than without but if the ambiant temps are on the cool side I suffer from head cold on any lengthy runs I could do with the seat being lowered by a few more inches and I'm only 5' 11''.trigg35 wrote:guess im in the minority but i like the look of the mesh type and mine is zipped up all the time hood up or down.when the hood is up it adds a bit of privacy
If you like gaming with mature minded players visit our retirement home http://www.oap-clan.co.uk/
I would like to point out I don't have any problem with the actual wind deflector regards quality, I think it looks better than the mesh (just my opinion though) it's well thought out and made and being tinted looks good, it would seem as a poster above has stated I could do with the seat being a few inches lower as I said my wife who is only 5ft has no problem at all, I could do with trying a mesh one to see if it's any better before I buy one, but I have a feeling I will not see any difference.
-
- Joined: Sun 23 Aug, 2009 07:14
- Posts: 77
- Location: Worcester
I've never been worried about wind in the cabin - after all its supposed to be 'wind in your hair' driving...
I bought a mesh deflector just before Christmas time purely because of the drop in temperature (much better price in the winter!). I still get a cold left ear with the deflector, but it helps keep the warmth from the heater in the cabin. Was able to drive roof down in minus temperatures without too much trouble.
Once the temperature is a little more consistent, the deflector will be going in the boot until the winter.
Gary
I bought a mesh deflector just before Christmas time purely because of the drop in temperature (much better price in the winter!). I still get a cold left ear with the deflector, but it helps keep the warmth from the heater in the cabin. Was able to drive roof down in minus temperatures without too much trouble.
Once the temperature is a little more consistent, the deflector will be going in the boot until the winter.
Gary
BMW Z3 2.0 Titan Silver - Progress Thread
(Pictures - http://s852.photobucket.com/home/gazhyde/allalbums)
(Pictures - http://s852.photobucket.com/home/gazhyde/allalbums)
I have 4 hats in the Zed - 2 baseball caps (to keep the sun out of my eyes + one for a passenger), 1 beanie (for my left ear) and 1 bizarre tartan thing with ear flaps (for the minus temperatures)... I just don't like wearing them!Julie Z3 wrote: get a woolie hat, it works for me
BMW Z3 2.0 Titan Silver - Progress Thread
(Pictures - http://s852.photobucket.com/home/gazhyde/allalbums)
(Pictures - http://s852.photobucket.com/home/gazhyde/allalbums)
Toying with wearing my Russian Army hat, with flaps up of course!GazHyde wrote:I have 4 hats in the Zed - 2 baseball caps (to keep the sun out of my eyes + one for a passenger), 1 beanie (for my left ear) and 1 bizarre tartan thing with ear flaps (for the minus temperatures)... I just don't like wearing them!Julie Z3 wrote: get a woolie hat, it works for me
Hats would mess my hair up though
If you like gaming with mature minded players visit our retirement home http://www.oap-clan.co.uk/
The saga continues, have bought a Mesh Wind Deflector removed the perspex one and fitted it, today (a lovely day to say the least) I have been out for a spin and have to say there is no difference it's still a gale force 7, looks like that I sit too tall in the car (everything is as low as it can go) so going to have to live with it and buy a hat, only thing now is which wind deflector do I sell one is brand new and the other is as new......decisions..........decisions....?
MickJ wrote:The saga continues, have bought a Mesh Wind Deflector removed the perspex one and fitted it, today (a lovely day to say the least) I have been out for a spin and have to say there is no difference it's still a gale force 7, looks like that I sit too tall in the car (everything is as low as it can go) so going to have to live with it and buy a hat, only thing now is which wind deflector do I sell one is brand new and the other is as new......decisions..........decisions....?
I too have had both wind deflectors in the past, and as you say there is not a lot of difference between them.
I kept the perspex one because of the better vision. But thats just a personal preference.
I wonder if installing the spacer mod to increase the seat height at the front would make any difference?
If you like gaming with mature minded players visit our retirement home http://www.oap-clan.co.uk/